Top Story
Emerging Trends Debate in Edinburgh
ULI UK presented the findings of the ULI/PwC Emerging Trends in Real Estate Europe 2018 report in Edinburgh on 23rd January. Kindly hosted
22 February 2018
On one of his swings past London this week, I had the pleasure of hosting Parag Kanna for an evening ULI session at AECOM. Parag, with his ever-roving attention, is finishing up a new book centred on the emerging dynamics of South-East Asia.
But during this particular presentation and the lively discussion that followed, we focused on how globalism and diversity are colliding with protectionism and solidarity, and tried to address a few questions:
Parag outlined three ideas that underpinned the discussion:
“The 2nd Law of (Geopolitical) Thermodynamics’: maximum entropy.”
“Devolution contributes to peace.”
“Tribalism is a path to globalism”
Parag noted that infrastructure is increasingly a more powerful authority than conventional political government; cross border infrastructure (e.g. continental gas networks , transport) reshapes cross-border relations. Connectivity makes it difficult to maintain monopolies because producer leverage becomes increasingly limited.
While the raging culture wars remain distracting, the world is remapping itself as functional geographies – connectivity and flow is becoming more important than conventional political territory, even after the relative constrictions after the Western financial crisis. (Note: I later had some side-chatter with Parag about data points related to global flows, and he steered me to this interesting McKinsey report: https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/global-flows-in-a-digital-age)
As nations devolve into urban regions, these mega-cities and their related urban corridors do create inequalities with their hinterlands. But they also continue to absorb population on a global basis, agglomerating the vast majority of talent, innovation, and investment. And we already know that rates of urbanization are already the most accurate proxy for determining electoral results.
The mega-cities, connected to global flows, create foundations for new forms of governance appropriate to the era (a gradual evolution from the 19th-century ‘Nation State’, the Cold War ‘Garrison State’, the globalised ‘Market State’, and the industry-cluster-based ‘Region State’.) We are now – formally and informally – developing the emerging ‘Info-State’, which in turn creates a new range of characteristics related to geographic scale, technology strategy, and diplomatic style. Parag described how we might build ‘ the most boring but effective government’: the hybrid ‘Direct Technocracy’ – something in between the ‘Direct Democracy’ of Switzerland and the ‘Technocracy’ of Singapore.
In the end, if we want to get these emerging cities right, especially in cultures that have democratic traditions and expectations, we need not only to have the ability to input into government, but also for the government to perform, for us to reliably receive related outputs. The ‘Info-State’, with its data-driven scenario analysis, real-time public consultation, and crowd sourcing of ideas’ is perhaps best placed to satisfy these expectations.
Words by Christopher Choa, ULI UK Chair
Don’t have an account? Sign up for a ULI guest account.